Benefits
Live automatic transcription in the classroom provides several key benefits that enhance learning, accessibility, and engagement for students and instructors alike:
- Accessibility for Students with Disabilities
- Supports deaf and hard-of-hearing students by providing real-time captions.
- Helps students with learning disabilities who may struggle with auditory processing.
- Enhances Comprehension and Retention
- Allows students to read along while listening, reinforcing understanding.
- May provide a text record that helps with note-taking and review.
- Assists non-native speakers in following along more easily.
- Improves Engagement and Focus
- Helps students stay on track during lectures by providing a visual reference.
- Reduces distractions and the need for students to multitask between listening and note-taking.
- Allows for better participation, as students can focus on discussion rather than just capturing notes.
- Supports Note-Taking and Study Strategies
- Provides a real-time text version of the lecture that students can highlight and annotate.
- Reduces cognitive load, allowing students to focus on deeper learning.
- Enables instant searchability, making it easier to review key concepts.
- Aids Non-Native English Speakers
- Helps ESL students understand spoken content more effectively.
- Provides real-time translation in some platforms, assisting multilingual learners.
- Supports pronunciation and vocabulary building by reinforcing spoken language with text.
- Facilitates Remote and Hybrid Learning
- Ensures equal access for students attending virtually.
- Provides a backup for technical issues (e.g., poor audio quality).
- Some platforms allow for post-class transcription review for students who missed a lecture.
- Supports Instructor Feedback and Lecture Improvements
- Instructors can review transcripts to assess clarity and pacing.
- Helps detect common misunderstandings among students.
- Allows for quick creation of lecture summaries and study guides.
- Promotes Inclusivity and Equity
- Ensures that all students, regardless of ability or language proficiency, have equal access to content.
- Aligns with universal design for learning (UDL) principles, making content more flexible and engaging.
By integrating live automatic transcription into classrooms, institutions can foster a more inclusive, engaging, and effective learning environment for all students.
Top
Issues and concerns
While live automatic captions offer many benefits in classrooms, there are also several issues and concerns that educators and institutions should consider:
- Accuracy Limitations
- Misinterpretations and Errors: Automatic captions may struggle with technical terms, accents, and speech clarity, leading to miscommunication.
- Contextual Mistakes: AI struggles with homophones (e.g., their vs. there) and sentence structure, which can affect comprehension.
- Mathematical and Scientific Notation Issues: Many AI captioning systems don't handle symbols, equations, or complex terminology well.
- Latency and Delay
- Processing Time: Some services have a delay (1-5 seconds), which can disrupt real-time engagement.
- Impact on Discussions: Captions lagging behind can make it harder for students to follow live Q/A sessions.
- Lack of Customization and Speaker Identification
- No Speaker Differentiation: Most automatic captions do not label different speakers, making dialogues harder to follow.
- Minimal Formatting Options: Some systems lack features like bold, italics, or structured note-taking integration.
- Accessibility and Usability Concerns
- Not Always ADA-Compliant: Due to accuracy issues, machine captions alone may not meet accessibility legal requirements (e.g., ADA, Section 508).
- Difficult for Students with Certain Disabilities: Students with low vision or cognitive processing difficulties may struggle if captions are too fast or inaccurate.
- Privacy and Data Security Risks
- Recording and Data Storage: Some tools store transcripts, which may raise FERPA or GDPR concerns in educational settings.
- Potential for Misuse: AI-based transcription services often send data to cloud servers, which may pose confidentiality risks for sensitive discussions.
- Dependence on Technology and Internet Connectivity
- Requires a Strong Internet Connection: Poor internet can reduce captioning quality or cause disconnects.
- Device and Software Compatibility: Some platforms don't work well across all operating systems, limiting accessibility for some students.
- Cost and Licensing Issues
- Premium Services Are Expensive: High-accuracy captions (e.g., Verbit, 3Play Media) require subscription or per-minute fees.
- Institutional Budget Constraints: Schools may have limited funding to provide professional captioning for all classes.
- Potential for Distraction
- Divided Attention: Some students may focus more on reading than on engaging with class discussions.
- Too Much Text on Screen: Dense, rapid captions can be overwhelming, making it hard to keep up.
- Equity and Language Limitations
- Limited Language Support: Many AI captioning tools primarily support English, leaving out students who speak less common languages.
- Struggles with Heavy Accents and Dialects: Some systems have poor recognition for non-standard English or regional accents.
- Ethical Considerations in AI Use
- Bias in AI Models: Speech recognition systems often work better for certain demographics (e.g., native English speakers).
- Lack of Human Oversight: Automated captions don't detect tone, sarcasm, or emotional context, which can cause misunderstandings.
In summary, while live automatic captions can enhance accessibility and engagement; their limitations, accuracy, privacy, cost, and accessibility compliance must be carefully managed. Many institutions opt for a hybrid approach, combining AI-generated captions with human review for improved reliability.
Top
Tools and services
When selecting a live automatic captioning provider consider factors such as; accuracy, latency, language support, customization options, platform integration, cost, and privacy features to ensure the service aligns with your specific needs.
The University of Maryland does not have a master contract with live captioning service providers. Below is a list of third-party vendors that offer live captioning services. While this is not an official endorsement, we hope this list is a helpful resource for those looking to incorporate live captions into their classes or events. Here are some options:
Google auto live caption - free, transcript not available
Automatically generates captions for media playing on Android devices and Chrome browsers. Supports over 40 languages with a latency of 1-3 seconds. Integrated into Android and Chrome platforms, making it a free and convenient option for users.
PowerPoint real-time automatic captions - free, transcript not available
PowerPoint's Live Captions and Subtitles feature provides real-time captions and translation in 60+ languages, enhancing accessibility and engagement. It allows customization of caption position, font, and color, works with built-in and external microphones, and is available in Microsoft 365. However, it has accuracy issues, lacks speaker differentiation, requires an internet connection for translations, and does not automatically save transcripts. While useful for multilingual presentations and accessibility, it may need manual review or professional captions for high-stakes use.
Otter.ai - paid, transcript generated
Provides real-time transcription and captioning services, primarily supporting English. Features extensive customization options and integrates seamlessly with platforms like Zoom, Google Meet, and Microsoft Teams. Operates on a subscription-based model.
Rev ai - paid, transcript generated
Offers automatic speech recognition services with support for over 31 languages. Provides a latency of 1-2 seconds and integrates with platforms such as Zoom, YouTube, and Vimeo. Operates on a pay-per-minute pricing model.
Microsoft azure speech - paid, transcript generated
Microsoft Azure Speech is a cloud-based AI service that provides real-time speech-to-text, text-to-speech, and speech translation capabilities. It is part of Azure Cognitive Services and is widely used for automatic transcription, voice assistants, and accessibility solutions. Delivers real-time captioning with support for over 80 languages and dialects. Features extensive customization options and integrates with Azure services, Microsoft Teams, and PowerPoint. Offers usage-based pricing and complies with GDPR and HIPAA standards.
Descript - paid, transcript generated
Descript is an AI-powered transcription service that offers automatic transcription with accuracy and speed. Provides transcription and captioning services supporting English and Spanish. Offers moderate customization options and integrates with platforms like YouTube and Zoom. Operates on a subscription-based model.
Verbit - paid, transcript generated
Specializes in providing captioning services with support for over 35 languages. Offers extensive customization options and integrates with webinars, virtual classrooms, and custom APIs. Provides custom pricing models and complies with GDPR and HIPAA standards.
Top